What is Atheism? -- Distinguishing Atheism from Agnosticism

90 posts / 0 new
Last post
Shock of God's picture
Well, if you're asking for

Well, if you're asking for evidence of something, and don't believe it exists, doesn't that defeat the purpose of asking for evidence?

Spewer's picture
Not in the least. My purpose

Not in the least. My purpose for asking for evidence is to show that the lack of evidence for FSM and the lack of evidence for your god are identical.

PsychoSarah's picture
This is all getting out of

This is all getting out of hand, no one is going to budge here, so why don't we all just respect a difference of opinion and leave it at that?

Spewer's picture
What was I thinking arguing

What was I thinking arguing here in "The Debate Room"?

Shock of God's picture
But, there isn't a lack of

But, there isn't a lack of evidence for God.

Spewer's picture
To you, perhaps, but so far,

To you, perhaps, but so far, the evidence you have presented for your god's existence is the historical existence of Jesus. I have no problem believing that a teacher we call Jesus existed and was executed by the Romans. What you have not established, to my satisfaction anyway, is how that existence would constitute evidence of the existence of any god, the existence of the supernatural, or the nonexistence of other beings. Please make that case.

In another thread, you have presented a case that the universe requires a cause. Even if I accept that (which I don't necessarily), it's a huge logical leap to go from the universe requires a cause to therefore *your* god exists.

JahLive's picture
Hmmm the flying spaghetti

Hmmm the flying spaghetti monster.. Sounds yummy haha

You may find this philisophical argument video called 'Why believe in God' interesting: http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=vwMKRuQqb04

Schibaka's picture
Man Shock of god. I think im

Man Shock of god. I think im saying this on behalf of allot of people on this forum.
Take your shitty God and leave this forum

We are tired of your God ranting, you are simply in the wrong forum.
Spread your horseshit somewhere else

Shock of God's picture
Was that supposed to offend

Was that supposed to offend me or make me feel bad? Because all it did is show how ignorant you really are.

PsychoSarah's picture
Ok, my patience is gone Shock

Ok, my patience is gone Shock of God. I have attempted to be decent with you, but you just keep crapping on peoples' ideas and completely ruin the debate by your unwillingness to even acknowledge the possibility that you might be wrong or even the intellectual value of other peoples' positions. None of us really know if there is a god or not, so stop acting as though you know what the best beliefs and theories are because your theories are no more likely to be correct than anyone else's.

Shock of God's picture
I acknowledge that I might be

I acknowledge that I might be wrong, but the probability of atheism being wrong is just a *tad* higher than the probability of my belief being wrong, as I have shown.
I'm not crapping on people's ideas. You guys need to stop blaming me for having unsound arguments that can be easily refuted. If I can refute an argument and show why it is wrong, then I will do so. That doesn't make me narrow-minded, rude, mean, crude, stupid, illogical, or anything of the sort. That makes me a good debater, which I seem to be since you all are getting mad at me for constantly vitiating your claims.
Atheism may be true, but there is good evidence to suggest that it is not.

PsychoSarah's picture
Why are your claims so much

Why are your claims so much better? Because you believe them? You cannot refute any claims with opinions, and while you may decided to post links to your information, ours isn't exactly without a source. And you know what? You Are Not Welcome Here because of rudeness, not for your ideas. You don't have to accept the opinions of others, but you shouldn't feel the need to disprove them. No one is going to stop being atheist because of you. In fact, you ruin the reputations of other religious people. You and other people like you are the reason why half the people hear can't stand theists.

Shock of God's picture
But, I'm not being rude.

But, I'm not being rude. Rude -- "discourteous or impolite, especially in a deliberate way." I have not been discourteous or impolite, especially in a deliberate way. You may *think* I have, but I have made no negative or offensive remarks toward a single user of this website. Yet I've been ridiculed and persecuted multiple times and have been falsely accused of being rude.
Secondly, the information I provide to negate atheistic claims are not opinions, they are pieces of information from science and history. May I ask you what the purpose of a debate is? It is for two people representing two different views to discuss a topic, and refute the other's claims.
Once again, I am not trying to make you stop being an atheist, if I wanted to do that, I would have made that blatantly obvious. My posts are made in the debate room, meaning they are up for debate, as are yours.
Also, I do accept the opinions of others. I am not showing that atheism is wrong, I am showing the some of the evidence that atheism is based off of is wrong.
It's not my fault if you can't stand a theist, It's not my job to make you like me. My job is to represent a Christian viewpoint on this website to help atheists better understand the world for a theistic viewpoint. I am also here to show why *some* atheistic thinking is wrong or logically invalid. You don't have to accept that it is, but if I can show that it is wrong, then it must be wrong, otherwise one would not be able to vitiate the claim.
Once again, don't get mad at me because I'm a good debater and know how to successfully refute claims.
Also, my claims are not necessarily better, but they are more sound than *some* of the atheistic arguments because they have not been refuted, yet I've been able to refute many atheistic claims. This is the point of a debate, to show why the opposing view is invalid and to use evidence to support your claims. If I am not allowed to debate in a debate room, then there should not be one on this website.

PsychoSarah's picture
And your goal is not being

And your goal is not being reached. Name on atheist on here who has actually maintained any respect for you. Without respect, no one will listen to you, logical or illogical. But you are literally an inch away from being shunned.

Shock of God's picture
I'm done discussing this

I'm done discussing this matter.
I have established that I'm not being rude; I have not once insulted a user or even so much as cursed on this website. I have been very formal in my debates.
I have established that I am not trying to convert anybody; I don't like people who try to convert. I am also not trying to impose my beliefs on anybody, apologies if it seems like I did.
I have established that I have not been disrespectful to anybody; not once have I insulted or disrespected a user on this website. Though, I have been insulted and disrespected.
Any more discussion on this particular topic will draw unnecessary and unwanted drama to this website. I encourage everybody to drop the subject and continue on their way, discussing it further will only enrage users even more, and that would not be a good thing.

PsychoSarah's picture
The issue of not liking you,

The issue of not liking you, or the entire debate of whether or not atheism is logical?

Shock of God's picture
The thing is, I never argued

The thing is, I never argued that atheism was illogical or that the atheist is irrational. What I argued was that the evidence that atheism rests upon is unsound and refutable.

PsychoSarah's picture
You have stated that your

You have stated that your entire mission is to prove atheism is illogical.

Shock of God's picture
I have stated that my entire

I have stated that my entire mission was to show that the evidence that atheism rests on can be easily refuted. I never said anything about atheism itself.

PsychoSarah's picture
-_- dude. I don't know if you

-_- dude. I don't know if you are just lying to yourself now or just being a troll.

PsychoSarah's picture
Ok, my patience is gone Shock

Ok, my patience is gone Shock of God. I have attempted to be decent with you, but you just keep crapping on peoples' ideas and completely ruin the debate by your unwillingness to even acknowledge the possibility that you might be wrong or even the intellectual value of other peoples' positions. None of us really know if there is a god or not, so stop acting as though you know what the best beliefs and theories are because your theories are no more likely to be correct than anyone else's.

PsychoSarah's picture
This is close to what you

This is close to what you sound like to us Shock of God http://youtu.be/zCdBZHBs0y0

Shock of God's picture
I am not a Creationist.

I am not a Creationist.

PsychoSarah's picture
Actually, this one is more

Actually, this one is more like you http://youtu.be/T7rXSrYswtU

Shock of God's picture
Once again, I am not a

Once again, I am not a creationist. These people are using their evidence to support creation. I don't do that. I accept the theory of evolution.

Zaphod's picture
LOL. Thanks for posting these

LOL. Thanks for posting these, I had to watch the rest. I think this was the funniest one of the series though!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xr2mjjSyvA4

PsychoSarah's picture
Their ignorance causes me

Their ignorance causes me physical pain. My brain cannot accept that I am of the same species as the beings that said that, so the turmoil gives me a massive headache. The worst was the lady that believed in god but not the existence of apes. Which you can see in a zoo.

UppityBiscuit's picture
I think so far you guys might

I think so far you guys might have been providing SoG with affirmation. Part of christian faith is seen to be tests of faith, persevering in the face of adversity. He/She might have been subconsciously fishing for this. heh, if so, that would sort of make Shock a fisher of men :-P

PsychoSarah's picture
The whole testing of faith

The whole testing of faith thing is a way of keeping people from tolerating any talk that deviates from the beliefs of the religion.

UppityBiscuit's picture
quite so, and it's pretty

quite so, and it's pretty damn effective.

Pages

Donating = Loving

Heart Icon

Bringing you atheist articles and building active godless communities takes hundreds of hours and resources each month. If you find any joy or stimulation at Atheist Republic, please consider becoming a Supporting Member with a recurring monthly donation of your choosing, between a cup of tea and a good dinner.

Or make a one-time donation in any amount.